Skip directly to site content
add bookmark

Oyster Stew Recipe

By Andrew Zimmern

Growing up in NYC and spending summers at sleep-away camp in Maine, I was exposed to many styles of this classic seafood soup. I think this version is unmatched—a beautiful marriage of intense brininess with decadent creaminess. It’s a comfort food dinner that your whole family will love, but also perfect for fall and winter parties where I like to serve it out of coffee mugs when guests come in the door. The key ingredient, of course, is fresh Maine oysters. Be sure to save the oyster liquor to fortify the broth.

64 ounces fresh shucked oysters, with their liquor 3 tablespoons minced bacon 1 cup sliced celery 1 cup sliced yellow onion 2 sprigs fresh thyme, rosemary and tarragon tied together in a bouquet garni 1 tablespoon paprika 1 tablespoon tomato paste 1 teaspoon Old Bay seasoning 3 tablespoons Worcestershire sauce 2 cups fresh fish stock or clam juice 1 quart heavy cream Chives, hot sauce, buttered toast and/or saltines, for serving

Strain the oysters through a sieve set over a bowl to catch the liquid. Reserve the liquid.

Place a large pot over medium high heat. Add the bacon, and allow to cook for a few minutes to render some fat.

Add all the Old Bay seasoning, celery, onion, paprika, tomato paste, and bouquet garni. Cook, being careful not to scorch the ingredients.

When onions are glassy, add the reserved oyster liquid and stock (or clam juice). Bring to a slow boil and cook for 10 minutes.

Add the cream. Cook, simmering for another 7-10 minutes, until cream thickens. Add the oysters and cook until liquids return to a slow boil.

Season with the Worcestershire sauce to taste, add some freshly ground black pepper and sea salt to taste, and serve with plenty of buttered toast, chives and hot sauce.

Businesses & Organizations

Retrieving results.
  • Monson Scoops is an ice cream shop owned by Monson General Store, serving Maine-made ice cream.

    Phone: (207) 997-3800


    Address: 16 Greenville Rd , Monson

    Local Maine Food
  • A completely new Foggy’s Pub is now open! Everyone is welcome to join us for a juicy burger, an artisan pizza, a house made entrée, a fresh salad, or a hand-crafted sandwich.

    Phone: 207.355.5515


    Address: 147 Lang Hill Road , Palmyra

    Caterers and Distributors Local Maine Food Maine Seafood
  • If you're looking for a fun pub open year round, you've found us! Doolin's Pub is dedicated to giving locals and visitors a place to chow down on delicious food and spend time with friends.

    Phone: (207) 268-3000


    Address: 495 Huntington Hill Road , Litchfield

    Caterers and Distributors Local Maine Food Maine Seafood
  • The newest microdistillery in Maine and 1st in Washington County

    Phone: (207) 483-8021


    Address: 1363 Main Street , Harrington

    Breweries, Wineries and Distilleries Local Maine Food
  • Sophisticated cuisine and rooftop bar in a harborside setting overlooking beautiful Camden, Maine

    Phone: 207-230-8035


    Address: 3 Wayfarer Drive , Camden

    Award-Winning Chefs Local Maine Food Maine Seafood
  • Serving delectable dishes that feature Maine’s fresh seafood, as well as other authentic American flavors, The Bangor Aviator Hotel's on-property restaurant is the perfect place to cruise in for a quality meal.

    Phone: (207) 947-6721


    Address: 308 Godfrey Blvd , Bangor, ME

    Lobster Local Maine Food Maine Seafood

Related Articles

Retrieving results.

Get inspired at the Maine Quarterly

  • Cara Stadler

  • Biddeford Food Scene

No results found.

Businesses and locations related to: Oyster Stew Recipe

Loading markers...

Searching for ""Almost there...